1976美国电影《不是幅漂亮局面》是由玛莎·库利奇导演的剧情片类型作品,又名Not a Pretty Picture,豆瓣评分,观看指数2,主要演员有里德·伯尼,Jim·Carrington,Michele·Manenti,黛安娜·岣特,Anne·Mundstuk等,不是幅漂亮局面在1976年上映播出。
剧情简介:
At the age of 16, Martha Coolidge was raped by a fellow student. This experience, and in particular the emotions and rhetoric in its aftermath, forms the starting point for this Brechtian film, in which Coolidge re-enacts the event and places the creative process in the foreground.
From the beginning, there is a clear distinction between the fictional scenes, in which the acting is deliberately slightly affected, and the documentary sequences, in which the actors discuss their roles and their own experiences. This produces a dialectical film about the gray areas of adolescent sex, and the web of insecurity, ignorance, privilege and performance pressure that can so easily turn into a toxic cocktail.
Coolidge further complicates matters in the intense rehearsal scenes, in which it is often not clear to the viewer what agreements have been made and whether they are being adhered to. Thus, these scenes themselves also enter gray areas, confronting the viewer with the ease with which boundaries can be blurred, shifted and crossed when they are not clearly drawn.
源自:https://festival.idfa.nl/en/film/ae49286a-02e8-4402-b6c0-5e7fa404c659/not-a-pretty-picture/
看点/点评
好心碎 让我想起太多熟悉的、糟糕的回忆 太多女孩子经历过的创伤 导演说经历这样的事情直到28岁她仍然无法进入亲密关系 最有趣的部分是导演观看着另一个女孩重演她最痛苦的回忆
导演和演员预拍摄期间讨论的镜头让观看这部电影更加艰难 - 电影中没有一丝一毫的虚构成分,所演即是所想、所相信,只有真实的痛苦被再次trigger,女主和室友抱在一起开心地说“我没有怀孕!!”也是同等让人难过,结尾导演说:I am 28 but I have not been in a committed relationship with a man. It has to be a special thing, that can’t possibly exist, for me to trust
3.5 其实cast一个rape victim然后无限地去即兴,排练,拍摄,重演那个traumatic event,真的本身没有ethical issue么。中段看得太不适而我不确定这种做法真的是那么必要的
6# 偶尔闪动着元叙事该有的光芒 在这样一个只能以意外的方式发生而完全无法预演的事件中嵌进排练和执导 更凸显其讽刺和反思 也能看出对后世的影响 但似乎因为缺乏一种更为先进的自然表演 叙事的游戏玩得不够彻底 场面调度仿佛习作 而导致整部电影最终成为not a pretty picture|Celine Sciamma的映前倒相当有趣 再度赞美她 /Dore
有同理心的物种会被没有同理心的杀光
前程和后程感觉不是一个导演的手笔,中段又极其难忍